Investigation 4

Diffusion and Osmosis

What causes my plants to wilt if I forget to water them?

Unit 2: Cell Structure and FunctionENE-1.BENE-1.CENE-2.HScience Practices 4.A, 5.A≈ 4 class periodsAbout 160 minutes in total
Overview

What you'll investigate

A wilted houseplant perks up within an hour of watering. Water moves into its cells, the cells press against their walls, and the stems stiffen again. In this lab you will work out why water moves, which way it goes, and how the size and shape of a cell limit how fast anything can get in or out.

The investigation has three procedures:

  1. Surface area and cell size. Soak agar "cells" that contain the pH indicator phenolphthalein in acid and watch the pink color disappear from the outside in. Measure how deep the acid gets and calculate what fraction of each block it reached.
  2. Modeling diffusion and osmosis. Fill dialysis-tubing bags with sucrose, salt, glucose, or protein solutions, soak them in a second solution, and use the change in mass to find the direction and rate of osmosis.
  3. Osmosis in living cells. Watch Elodea or onion cells plasmolyze under the microscope, then use potato cores in unlabeled sucrose solutions to find the water potential of plant tissue.

Finally you will design your own experiment, using any of these systems.

Learning objectives
  • ENE-1.B Explain the effect of surface area-to-volume ratios on the exchange of materials between cells or organisms and the environment.
  • ENE-1.C Explain how specialized structures and strategies are used for the efficient exchange of molecules to the environment.
  • ENE-2.H Explain how concentration gradients affect the movement of molecules across membranes.
Science practices
  • 5.A Perform mathematical calculations (surface area, volume, percent change, water potential).
  • 4.A Construct a graph, plot, or chart (percent change in mass against concentration).
Safety in the real lab

The 0.1 M HCl and 0.1 M NaOH solutions cause chemical burns. Wear goggles, gloves, and an apron, and keep the agar blocks and acid in a spill-proof tray. Your teacher prepares the concentrated solutions in a fume hood. Report every spill right away.

Background

Membranes, gradients, and water potential

Key ideas
  • The plasma membrane is selectively permeable: small nonpolar molecules cross easily, while ions and large polar molecules need transport proteins.
  • Diffusion is net movement down a concentration gradient and needs no energy from the cell.
  • As a cell grows, its surface area-to-volume ratio falls (cube: SA:V = 6/s), so exchange gets harder: that is why cells stay small.
  • Osmosis is the diffusion of water. Water moves toward the lower water potential.
  • Water potential ψ = ψP + ψS, with ψS = −iCRT. At equilibrium ψ inside a cell equals ψ outside.

A cell has to take in nutrients and get rid of wastes across its plasma membrane, a phospholipid bilayer with embedded proteins. The membrane is selectively permeable. Small nonpolar molecules slip through the lipid tails. Water crosses slowly through the bilayer and much faster through channel proteins called aquaporins. Ions and larger polar molecules such as sugars need channel or carrier proteins.

Diffusion is the net movement of a substance from where it is more concentrated to where it is less concentrated. It needs no energy from the cell; it happens because molecules are always moving randomly. Diffusion is faster when the temperature is higher (more kinetic energy), when the molecules are smaller, when the concentration gradient is steeper, and when the distance is shorter. At equilibrium molecules keep moving, but movement in each direction is equal, so there is no net change.

Why cells are small

Everything a cell exchanges has to pass through its surface, but the demand for exchange comes from its volume. As a cube grows, surface area grows with the square of the side length while volume grows with the cube, so the surface area-to-volume ratio (SA:V) falls. A large cell has too little membrane for its contents, and molecules diffusing inward take a long time to reach the center. Microvilli in the small intestine, root hairs, and the flattened shape of red blood cells all raise SA:V.

1 cm SA 6 · V 1 · SA:V 6 2 cm SA 24 · V 8 · SA:V 3 3 cm SA 54 · V 27 · SA:V 2
cube: SA = 6s²  ·  V = s³  ·  SA:V = 6/s   |   box: SA = 2(LW + LH + WH)  ·  V = LWH
Osmosis and tonicity

Osmosis is the diffusion of water across a selectively permeable membrane. Dissolved solutes hold water molecules in hydration shells, so a solution with more solute has less "free" water. Water therefore moves toward the side with more solute. Compared with another solution, a hypertonic solution has more solute, a hypotonic one has less, and isotonic solutions have equal water potential, so there is no net water movement. These words always compare two solutions; a solution is not hypertonic by itself.

Water potential

Plant cells have a rigid wall, so solute concentration alone does not predict water movement. Botanists use water potential (ψ, psi), measured in bars, which combines the effect of solutes and of pressure. Water always moves from higher ψ to lower ψ.

ψ = ψP + ψS     ψS = −iCRT
  • ψS, solute potential: always zero or negative. i is the ionization constant (1 for sucrose or glucose, 2 for NaCl), C the molar concentration, R = 0.0831 L·bar/(mol·K), and T the temperature in kelvins (273 + °C).
  • ψP, pressure potential: zero for a solution in an open beaker, positive (turgor pressure) inside a cell pushing on its wall, negative under tension in xylem.
  • Pure water in an open container has ψ = 0. Example: 0.15 M sucrose at 25 °C has ψS = −(1)(0.15)(0.0831)(298) = −3.7 bars; 0.15 M NaCl has twice that, −7.4 bars.

When a plant cell sits in pure water, water flows in and the cell pushes on its wall until turgor pressure cancels the cell's negative solute potential. Then ψ inside equals ψ outside, and net movement stops. In a solution with lower ψ than the cell, water leaves, turgor drops to zero, and the membrane pulls away from the wall. This is plasmolysis, and it is why an unwatered plant wilts.

Cell ψS = −7 · ψP = +3 ψ = −4 bars Solution ψS = −4 · ψP = 0 ψ = −4 bars Equal ψ: water crosses both ways at the same rate. wall membrane
What this simulation models
  • Process: Diffusion of acid into agar cubes, osmosis across dialysis tubing, plasmolysis in plant cells, and the water potential of plant tissue.
  • Included: The acid front grows with the square root of time and depends on acid concentration, temperature, and block size and shape. Each solute crosses the tubing at its own rate (protein not at all). Cells and cores respond to the difference in water potential. Specimens and the balance vary a little at random.
  • Simplified or left out: The acid front is perfectly sharp, living membranes block all solutes, and mass changes follow smooth curves. Real blotting, evaporation and temperature drift make class data scatter more.
Pre-lab check

Before you start

Use R = 0.0831 L·bar/(mol·K) and T = 273 + °C. Enter negative numbers with a minus sign.

Procedure 1 · Structured inquiry

Surface area and cell size

Before you begin: Measure the colorless depth from the cube surface toward its center. Record the depth in the same units as the cube dimensions.

Need a quick science reminder?

Diffusion depth is a distance, not the entire width of the colorless region. Keep cube dimensions and measured depths in the same units.

Your model cells are blocks of agar made with phenolphthalein and a little NaOH, so they start bright pink. When you soak them in acid, the acid diffuses inward and neutralizes the base. Wherever the acid has reached, the agar turns colorless. Before you cut, think about the epithelial cells lining the small intestine and plant root hairs: what shape are they, and how does that shape help them take in nutrients?

Step 1 · Test the indicator

Tube 1 Tube 2

Each tube holds a few drops of 1% phenolphthalein. Add a reagent and record what you see.

Steps 2–3 · Cut blocks and soak them in acid

Controls

More options
Full procedure

After soaking, each block is sliced through the middle and the colorless band is measured with a ruler (to the nearest 0.5 mm).

Your job: do the math

For each block, fill in surface area, volume, SA:V, and the percent of the volume the acid reached. The block that is still pink has dimensions (L − 2d) × (W − 2d) × (H − 2d), where d is the depth in cm. So the percent diffused is 100 × (1 − pink volume ÷ total volume). Then check your work.

Time in acid0 min
Acid front0.0 mm
Front speed—

Procedure 2 · Structured inquiry

Modeling diffusion and osmosis

Controls

BagInside bagIn cup
Full procedure

You are in the hospital and need fluids through an IV. Why does the bag contain salts instead of pure water, and how would someone find the right concentration? To start answering, you will build model cells from dialysis tubing. Its pores let water and small solutes (ions, glucose, and more slowly, sucrose) through but block large molecules such as proteins and starch.

Procedure. Knot one end of each 20 cm tube, add 10 mL of the inside solution, and knot the other end, leaving room for water to enter. Blot and weigh each bag, place it in a cup of the second solution for 30 minutes, then blot and weigh it again. Bag 5, with water inside and out, is your control. Predict the direction of water movement for each pair before you run it.

Run the set again to collect replicates. The balance reads to 0.01 g.

Time0 min
Largest gain—
Largest loss—

Fill in % change in mass = (final − initial) ÷ initial × 100 for each bag, then check your work. The graph shows the mean for each pair, with error bars of ±2 SE once you have replicates.

Procedure 3 · Part A

Observing osmosis in living cells

Controls

More options
Full procedure

Mount a single Elodea leaf (or a strip of red onion epidermis) in a drop of water and view it at 400×. Find the cell wall and the cell membrane. Can you tell them apart? Then add one of the solutions from Procedure 2 at the edge of the cover slip and draw it under with a paper towel on the opposite side. Watch what happens to the protoplast, the membrane-bound contents of the cell.

Count the cells inside the outlined field whose membrane has pulled away from the wall, and type that number in the table.

Bathing solutionDistilled water
ψ of solution0.0 bars
Time since added—
Procedure 3 · Part B

Finding the water potential of plant tissue

Your teacher made six sucrose solutions (0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, and 1.0 M) and dyed each a different color, but did not label which is which. First you need to work out the concentrations. Then soak cores of plant tissue in each one overnight and use the change in mass to find the concentration that is isotonic to the tissue. From that you can calculate the tissue's water potential.

Step 1 · Identify the color-coded solutions

Controls

More options
Stuck? Reveal the labels

Only use this if your teacher allows it.

Full procedure

One way to rank the solutions: put a water-filled dialysis bag in each cup for 30 minutes. Water leaves the bag faster when the cup has more sucrose.

Step 2 · Soak plant cores overnight

Controls

Full procedure

Four cores from a cork borer go in each cup. The four are weighed together before and after soaking overnight at 22 °C.

Run each tissue at least twice to get replicate cups.

The dashed lines are least-squares fits. Each fit equation is printed under the graph. The isotonic concentration is where the line crosses 0% change, the x-intercept = −b ÷ m.

Soak time0 h
TissueWhite potato

Step 3 · Calculate the tissue's water potential

Water potential: calculation guide
  1. Find the graph's x-intercept: where predicted mass change is 0%.
  2. At this isotonic point, ψtissue = ψsolution.
  3. For the open cup, calculate ψ = −iCRT.

Use concentration in mol/L and temperature in kelvin. Report water potential in bars.

At the isotonic point

When there is no net change in mass, ψtissue = ψsolution. The solution is in an open cup, so ψP = 0 and ψsolution = ψS = −iCRT. Use T = 295 K (22 °C) and i = 1 for sucrose.

Water potential calculator

Controls

ψS = −iCRT
ψS—
ψP—
ψ = ψP + ψS—

Designing and conducting your investigation

Design your own experiment

Controls

More options
Held constant

Full procedure

Each procedure raised questions you have not answered yet. Does shape matter as much as size? How does temperature change the speed of diffusion? How does the gradient's size affect the rate of osmosis? Pick one independent variable, plan your levels and replicates, and write down your design before you run anything.

Dependent variable—
Trend (slope, y-units per x-unit)—
R²—
Analyzing results

Make sense of your data

Need to check water potential and the measurements used to calculate it? Review that investigation section before interpreting your results.

How do I connect diffusion, osmosis, and my data?
  1. Compare cube sizes fairly. Use the percentage of each cube reached by acid, not just diffusion depth. Explain how surface-area-to-volume ratio helps account for the pattern.
  2. Interpret mass changes. A gain in tissue mass suggests net water entry; a loss suggests net water exit. Use your measured values to support the direction of movement.
  3. Locate the isotonic point. Look for the sucrose concentration where the predicted percentage change in mass is zero. Explain why this indicates no net water movement, not that water stops moving.
  4. Evaluate your estimate. Consider variation among tissue cores, concentration identification, and measurement precision before drawing a conclusion.

Use evidence from your own tables and graphs rather than assuming every tissue responds the same way.

Evaluate and extend

Where can you go from here?

Wrap up

Save and hand in your work