Investigation 6

Cellular Respiration

What factors affect the rate of cellular respiration in multicellular organisms?

Unit 3: Cellular EnergeticsENE-1.KENE-1.LScience Practices 4.A, 6.B≈ 4 class periodsAbout 130 minutes in total
Overview

What you'll investigate

Seeds sitting in a dish do not look busy, but a germinating seed is burning through its stored food as fast as a small insect. In this lab you will measure that activity by tracking how much oxygen gas living things remove from a sealed chamber.

You will build (virtually) a microrespirometer: a 1 mL syringe sealed to a thin capillary tube, with a drop of KOH to soak up carbon dioxide. As the seeds use O2, a tiny plug of colored fluid creeps down the capillary toward the seeds. You will mark its position every 5 minutes, correct your readings with a control respirometer full of glass beads, graph O2 consumed against time, and get the respiration rate from the slope. You will also try the electronic version (O2, CO2, or gas pressure sensors), and then design your own experiment on temperature, seed type, germination age, light, or small animals.

Learning objectives
  • ENE-1.K Describe the processes that allow organisms to use energy stored in biological macromolecules.
  • ENE-1.L Explain how cells obtain energy from biological macromolecules in order to power cellular functions.
Science practices
  • 4.A Construct a graph, plot, or chart (O2 consumed vs. time; rate vs. a variable).
  • 6.B Support a claim with evidence from biological principles, concepts, processes, and/or data.
Safety in the real lab
  • Potassium hydroxide (KOH, or NaOH in drain cleaner) is caustic. Wear goggles, gloves, and an apron the whole time.
  • Use only one small drop of KOH, held in cotton. When you push the plunger in, point the capillary into a sink: extra KOH can squirt out.
  • Hot glue guns burn. Let the glue cool before you touch the capillary joint.
  • Work only with your teacher supervising.
Background

Turning gas volume into a respiration rate

Key ideas
  • Respiration uses O2 to oxidize glucose and releases CO2, so you can follow it by the O2 that disappears from a sealed chamber.
  • Respiration makes CO2 while it uses O2 (one for one with glucose; a bit less CO2 with oils). KOH removes all the CO2, so the gas volume falls only because O2 is consumed.
  • Gas volume also changes with temperature and pressure (PV = nRT), so a control respirometer of glass beads corrects for them.
  • Plug travel (cm) × 5.03 µL/cm gives O2 used (µL). The slope of O2 vs. time is the respiration rate.
  • Q10 compares rates 10 °C apart; most respiration has a Q10 of 2 to 3 until enzymes denature.

Every living cell needs a steady supply of free energy to build molecules, move materials, and stay organized. Plants capture energy through photosynthesis, but almost all of their cells, like ours, also have mitochondria and run cellular respiration to turn stored carbon compounds into ATP. A germinating seed cannot photosynthesize yet, so it lives entirely on the starch or oil packed into its cotyledons or endosperm.

When enough oxygen is present, glucose is oxidized completely in a series of enzyme-catalyzed steps:

C6H12O6 + 6 O2 → 6 CO2 + 6 H2O + energy (≈ 686 kcal per mole of glucose)
Choosing what to measure, and why KOH

You could measure respiration by tracking any of the three things that change: O2 used, CO2 made, or heat released. Heat is hard to catch. Gas volumes are easier, but there is a catch: for glucose, one CO2 is released for every O2 consumed, so the total amount of gas in a sealed chamber barely changes. The trick is to remove the CO2 as soon as it forms. Potassium hydroxide does this by turning the gas into a solid:

CO2 + 2 KOH → K2CO3 + H2O

Now the only gas change left is the loss of O2, so the gas volume in the chamber shrinks. The shrinking gas pulls the fluid plug in the capillary toward the chamber.

The microrespirometer
Diagram of a microrespirometer: a capillary tube with a fluid plug sits above a syringe barrel that holds KOH-soaked cotton, a protective cotton plug, and germinating seeds. The barrel is submerged in a water bath. water bath, 20 °C Fluid plug (manometer fluid) moves toward the chamber as O₂ is used Capillary tube, open at top Absorbent cotton + 1 drop KOH CO₂ + 2KOH → K₂CO₃ + H₂O Non-absorbent cotton (shields seeds) Germinating seeds take in O₂, give off CO₂ Washers (sink it) Plunger at 1.0 mL mark
The gas law and the control respirometer

Gas volume also responds to things that have nothing to do with the seeds. The ideal gas law ties them together:

PV = nRT   →   V = nRT / P

Respiration lowers n (moles of gas), which lowers V. But if the water bath warms by a fraction of a degree, V goes up; if air pressure in the room rises, V goes down. That is why every experiment needs a control respirometer filled with non-living glass beads (or baked seeds) of the same volume. It sits in the same bath, so any movement of its plug comes only from temperature and pressure changes. Subtracting the control's movement from the seeds' movement leaves the part caused by respiration.

From plug movement to a rate

To turn plug movement into a gas volume, treat the inside of the capillary as a cylinder. Our capillaries have an inner radius of 0.040 cm, so each centimeter of travel is

V = πr²h = π(0.040 cm)²(1 cm) = 0.00503 cm³ = 5.03 µL of O2

Plot O2 consumed (µL) on the y-axis against time (min) on the x-axis. The slope of the best-fit line is the respiration rate in µL O2/min. Dividing by the mass of the organisms gives a rate per gram, which lets you compare organisms of different sizes.

Temperature and Q10

Respiration is a chain of enzyme reactions, so it speeds up with temperature until the enzymes start to denature. Biologists summarize the temperature effect with the Q10, the factor by which a rate increases for a 10 °C rise. Most respiration has a Q10 between 2 and 3:

Q10 = (R2 / R1)10 / (T2 − T1)
What this simulation models
  • Process: Cellular respiration. Organisms take in O2 and give off CO2; with KOH absorbing the CO2, the gas in a respirometer shrinks as O2 is used.
  • Included: Organism type and mass, temperature (Q10, and heat damage above about 40 °C), germination age of seeds, light on green seedlings, the bead control, bath temperature and air-pressure drift, skipping equilibration, and O2, CO2 and pressure sensor readings.
  • Simplified or left out: Each organism has one typical rate per gram plus random variation, and the respiratory quotient is fixed. Leaks, water vapor and most changes in animal activity are not modeled, so real readings wobble more.
Getting started

Before you start

These questions review key ideas. Answer each one, then check it. Read the explanation even when you are right.

Procedure · Option 1 · Structured inquiry

Measure respiration with microrespirometers

Before you begin: Record the experimental and glass-bead control readings separately. Then use both readings to calculate corrected oxygen consumption.

Need a quick science reminder?

The glass-bead control captures changes unrelated to respiration. Keep raw readings separate from corrected oxygen consumption.

Controls

More options
Experimental respirometer0.5 mL germinating Wisconsin Fast Plant seeds (≈ 0.30 g), soaked 2 days
Control respirometer0.5 mL glass beads
Water bath20 °C (room temperature)

Positions are marked every 5 min, like the marker lines you would draw on the capillary. The ruler next to each tube starts at the time-0 mark.

Full procedure: building the respirometers
  1. Push a 40 µL plastic capillary into the tip of a 1 mL tuberculin syringe (no needle) as far as the plunger tip, and seal the joint with hot glue. Check that the glue did not plug the capillary.
  2. Draw soapy red manometer fluid through the capillary and push it out again. The soap film stops the plug from sticking.
  3. Pack a small plug of absorbent cotton to the 0 mL end of the barrel, add one small drop of 15% KOH, then add a plug of non-absorbent cotton on top to protect the seeds.
  4. Push the plunger in (capillary pointed into a sink) to remove excess KOH, then remove the plunger.
  5. Add 0.5 mL of germinating seeds and push the plunger to the 1.0 mL mark. Build a second, identical respirometer with 0.5 mL of glass beads as the control.
  6. Slide 3–4 washers onto each barrel, set both in a 20 °C water bath with the barrels under water and the capillaries sticking out, and wait 5 minutes for temperatures to even out.
  7. Add one drop of manometer fluid to each capillary tip. It is pulled in and seals the chamber. Mark the bottom edge of each plug: this is time 0. Mark again every 5 minutes for 25 minutes.
Time0.0 min
Seeds: plug moved0.00 cm
Beads: plug moved0.00 cm
Corrected O₂ used0.0 µL

Table 1. Results using microrespirometers

The sim fills in the marked positions (columns C). You fill in the two white columns: the change in the seed plug's position during each 5-min interval, and the corrected distance (seed distance − bead distance). Open the Data tab beside the scene to do it, then check your work.

Graph: corrected O₂ consumed vs. time

O2 consumed (µL) = corrected distance (cm) × 5.03 µL/cm. The dashed line is the least-squares fit. The graph builds in the Graph tab beside the scene.

Find the rate

Use the graph (two well-separated points on the fit line, or the equation under it) to find the rate of respiration of the germinating seeds at 20 °C.

µL O₂/min

Replicate runs

One run is one data point. Each completed run adds its corrected rate to the replicate table (Data tab). Do at least three runs so you can report a mean and standard error.

Procedure · Option 2

Measure respiration with gas sensors

Many classrooms use a sensor plugged into a computer interface instead of microrespirometers. Here, 25 germinating peas sit in a 250 mL respiration chamber in a 20 °C water bath, and the sensor logs a reading every 30 seconds for 25 minutes. Try each sensor. Then think about which one needs KOH in the chamber, and why.

Controls

More options

Each completed run is added to the run table (Data tab).

Time0.0 min
Reading—
Slope (sensor units/min)—
≈ O₂ used—
Designing and conducting your investigation

Your own respiration experiment

Now you have a tool. Pick one question and test it.

Question ideas
  • Does temperature change the rate of respiration in germinating seeds? Do seeds use more O2 when it is warmer?
  • Do germinating seeds respire faster than non-germinating seeds? Do seeds just starting to germinate respire faster than seeds that have been germinating for several days?
  • Do oil-storing seeds (Wisconsin Fast Plants) respire at a different rate from starch-storing grass seeds (oats)? Monocots vs. dicots?
  • Can the same respirometer measure respiration in small invertebrates like mealworms, crickets, fruit flies, or earthworms? How do they compare per gram?
  • What happens if you use green seedlings in the light instead of seeds in the dark?
Table 2. Investigation proposal

Controls

More options
Fast respirers can pull the plug to the end of the capillary early. Read more often if that happens.

Every trial is paired with its own glass-bead control and corrected automatically. Rates are the slope of corrected O2 vs. time.

Last rate (µL O₂/min)—
Per gram (µL·g⁻¹·min⁻¹)—
Trials so far (count)0

Q10 calculator
Q10 formula

Q10 = (R2 ÷ R1)10/(T2 − T1)

Compare rates from the same organism and method; use °C for the temperature difference. Q10 = 2 means the rate doubles for a 10 °C increase over this interval.

Enter two mean rates measured 5–15 °C apart (same organism, everything else held constant).

Q₁₀ (ratio)—
Analyzing results

Make sense of your data

Need to revisit gas-volume measurements and respiration-rate calculations? Review the investigation steps before interpreting your results.

How do I compare respiration rates and sensor results?
  1. Separate raw and corrected readings. In a microrespirometer, use the glass-bead control to account for changes unrelated to respiration before comparing oxygen consumption.
  2. Use rates, not just endpoints. Compare changes in oxygen or carbon dioxide over the same time interval. Check the units and the direction of the trend.
  3. Interpret different sensors. Oxygen consumption and carbon dioxide production are related but distinct measurements. When KOH absorbs carbon dioxide, pressure or gas-volume changes can better reflect oxygen uptake.
  4. Explain the controls. Compare germinating and non-germinating peas or glass beads, and consider temperature and equilibration when interpreting differences.

Use your own graph and measurements to support the conclusion; do not assume the sensor readings measure the same gas process.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Answer the question you chose in your own investigation.

Evaluate and reflect

How good was your experiment?

Wrap up

Save and hand in your work