Investigation 9

Biotechnology: Restriction Enzyme Analysis of DNA

How can we use genetic information to identify and profile individuals?

Unit 6: Gene Expression and RegulationIST-1.PScience Practice 6.D≈ 2 class periods + gel runAbout 155 minutes in total
Overview

The case of the missing teacher

You arrive at AP Biology, Room 102. Chairs are knocked over, there is broken glass on the floor, there are drops of blood, and Ms. Mason is nowhere to be found. Your classmates Marcus and Laurel bag the evidence. Your job is to use DNA to find out whose blood is on the floor.

Evidence log
  • Ten small drops on the floor, confirmed as blood by a Kastle-Meyer test
  • A shard from a broken 500-mL Erlenmeyer flask with a reddish stain on the edge
  • A paper cup with lipstick, presumed to be Ms. Mason's (saliva)
  • A wad of bubble gum under an overturned chair (Bobby chews that brand)
  • A tissue Mr. Gladson, the teacher next door, threw in the hall trash
  • Bobby's photosynthesis test with a large red "F"
  • An email from Mr. Gladson asking Ms. Mason to give up her job as department chair

You will:

  1. Use restriction enzymes to cut DNA on paper, and predict the fragments from a map of lambda (λ) phage DNA.
  2. Cast, load and run a virtual agarose gel with uncut λ DNA and λ DNA cut with EcoRI, HindIII and BamHI.
  3. Measure how far each band moved, build a semi-log standard curve from the HindIII marker, and estimate the sizes of unknown fragments.
  4. Design and run your own gel of the crime-scene evidence. Then use your numbers, not just your eyes, to decide whose blood it is.
Learning objective and practice
  • IST-1.P Explain the use of genetic engineering techniques in analyzing or manipulating DNA.
  • Science Practice 6.D Explain the relationship between experimental results and larger biological concepts, processes, or theories.
Safety at the real bench
  • The gel box holds a salt buffer and uses DC current strong enough to shock you. Turn the power supply OFF and wait 10 seconds before touching any lead.
  • Connect black to black and red to red, then switch the power on. Power goes on last and off first.
  • Wear gloves. Never handle gels with bare hands, and keep methylene blue stain off your skin.
  • Hot agarose can boil over and scald you. Use heat-resistant gloves when you melt it.
Background

Cutting DNA and sorting it by size

Key ideas
  • A restriction enzyme cuts DNA at a specific short palindromic site, so the same DNA always gives the same fragments.
  • Differences between people add, remove or move sites, so fragment lengths differ (RFLPs).
  • In a gel, negatively charged DNA moves toward the + electrode; smaller fragments travel farther.
  • Distance migrated is roughly linear in log10(size), so a marker of known sizes gives a standard curve for sizing unknown bands.
  • A match needs sizes and a stated rule, not just bands that look alike.

Restriction enzymes (restriction endonucleases) are proteins bacteria use to chop up the DNA of invading viruses. Each one recognizes a specific short sequence, usually a 4- to 8-base-pair palindrome, which means the sequence reads the same 5′→3′ on both strands. The enzyme cuts the sugar–phosphate backbone at that site. EcoRI (from E. coli) recognizes 5′-GAATTC-3′ and cuts between G and A on each strand. Because the two cuts are staggered, each piece ends with a four-base single-stranded overhang, called a sticky end. Other enzymes, such as SmaI (CCC↓GGG), cut straight across and leave blunt ends. Fragments with matching sticky ends can base-pair and be sealed by DNA ligase. This "cut and paste" step is the basis of recombinant DNA.

5′3′ GAATTCCTTAAG 3′5′ EcoRI site: the cut (magenta) runs betweenG and A on each strand, 4 bases apart. 5′3′GCTTAA AATTCG3′5′ Two fragments, each with a single-stranded5′-AATT overhang (a "sticky end").
RFLPs: why people differ

Cutting a DNA molecule with an enzyme gives a set of fragments whose sizes depend on where the sites are. Differences between individuals' DNA can add or remove sites, or change the distance between them. This gives each person a different set of restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs). That pattern is a DNA "fingerprint." Identical twins have the same pattern.

How gel electrophoresis separates DNA

Gel electrophoresis separates the fragments. DNA's phosphate groups give it a negative charge, so in an electric field it moves from the negative (black) electrode toward the positive (red) electrode. That is why the wells go at the black end. The agarose gel is a mesh of pores. Short fragments slip through quickly, while long ones get tangled and move slowly. Over a useful range, the distance a fragment travels is roughly a straight-line function of the logarithm of its size:

distance ≈ a − b · log10(size in bp)   ⇔   log10(bp) = m · distance + c
Sizing fragments with a marker

To size unknown fragments, run a DNA marker (a set of fragments of known size) on the same gel. Here the marker is λ DNA cut with HindIII: 23,130, 9,416, 6,557, 4,361, 2,322, 2,027, 564 and 125 bp. Plot distance on the ordinary x-axis and size on the logarithmic y-axis of semi-log paper. The points fall close to a straight line, called the standard curve. Read an unknown band's distance across to the line to estimate its size. The very largest fragments squeeze together near the top (above about 20 kb at 0.8% agarose) and fall off the line, so leave them out of the fit. λ DNA has 12-base single-stranded "cos" ends that can stick together. In a HindIII digest, the two end fragments (23,130 + 4,361) partly pair up into a 27,491-bp piece that runs in the same band as 23,130.

Loading dye, agarose, voltage and time

Loading dye contains a dense sugar that makes the sample sink into the well. It also contains a blue-purple dye that runs at about the same speed as a 300-bp DNA fragment, so you can see how far the run has gone. Agarose concentration, voltage and run time all change how well the bands separate.

What this simulation models
  • Process: Restriction enzymes cut DNA at specific sequences, and gel electrophoresis separates the fragments by size so you can estimate their lengths.
  • Included: Real cut sites in λ DNA for EcoRI, HindIII and BamHI; migration that depends on the log of fragment size; agarose percentage, voltage and run time; volume loaded; band brightness from DNA mass; sticky λ ends that join unless heated; staining and destaining; small gel-to-gel differences.
  • Simplified or left out: Migration follows a smooth formula. Partial digests, damaged DNA and leaky wells are not modeled. Real gels smear and run unevenly, so your standard curve may scatter more.
Quick references (no memorization required)

Restriction sites: EcoRI G↓AATTC; HindIII A↓AGCTT; BamHI G↓GATCC. The arrow marks the cut on the displayed strand.

Dilution: C₁V₁ = C₂V₂. For 500 mL of 1× TAE from 50× stock: V₁ = (1 × 500) / 50 = 10 mL stock; add 490 mL water.

Pre-lab check

Before you start

Getting started · Activities I and II

Cut DNA on the computer, then map λ DNA

Here is a 53-bp template strand and its complement. Choose an enzyme and digest. Before you press the button, predict how many fragments you will get.

Controls

Restriction sites (count)—
Fragments (count)—

        

Restriction map of λ phage DNA (48,502 bp)

The real sites of three enzymes in the λ genome are shown below. Choose one or more enzymes to see the fragments they would produce. This is what is in each tube you will load.

Procedure · Learning to use gel electrophoresis

Load and run λ DNA digests

Before you begin: Select a sample tube, then tap or click an empty well to load it. Check the loading-order status to see which wells are already filled. When every sample is loaded, press Power on and watch the dye front.

Need a quick science reminder?

An open tube indicates the selected sample, not an empty tube. Check the status to see where it has already been loaded. DNA moves toward the positive (red) end of the gel, and smaller fragments generally travel farther. For restriction sites and the dilution formula, see Quick references in Background.

Why 0.8% agarose and 1× TAE? Agarose percentage (0.8% w/v = 0.8 g per 100 mL) describes the gel matrix; 1× TAE describes the working concentration of the electrophoresis buffer. These are different materials with different concentration units and do not need to match.

Your gel (0.8% agarose in 1× TAE) is cast, set in the box with the comb at the black (−) end, covered with buffer, and the comb has been removed. Load each sample into its own well: pick a tube, then click a well, either on the gel or with the well buttons (the load volume is under More options if you want to change it). Record your loading order. Connect the leads, press Power on, and run the gel until the dye front is about 1 cm from the end of the gel (about 60 mm on the Dye front readout). Then press Power off and stain the gel. A good order to load, with the uncut control and the digests side by side, is A BamHI, B EcoRI, C HindIII, D uncut.

Analyzing results · Sizing fragments

Measure bands and build a standard curve

Need the restriction-site sequences or dilution equation again? Review the quick references in Background. Your gel measurements will stay saved while you switch sections.

Important: You do not calculate the known marker sizes. The HindIII marker contains DNA fragments of already known lengths. First measure how far each visible marker band traveled, then enter its supplied size in the Known fragment size column. The standard curve uses those known pairs to estimate unknown fragment sizes. If a band is faint, overlapping, or not visible, do not invent a separate measurement.

After staining, click a band, or use "Measure all visible bands in lane." Each click adds the distance from the front of the well to the front edge of the band. Readings carry about ±0.5 mm of ruler error, as at the bench. In the Known fragment size column, type the size of each HindIII marker band, largest (closest to the well) first: 23,130 (the 23,130/27,491 doublet), 9,416, 6,557, 4,361, 2,322, 2,027 … The page fits log10(bp) against distance for each gel, then estimates every band with no known size.

Remember: The marker sizes are already known. Your job is to measure their travel distances and pair each distance with the correct supplied size.

Your measurement checklist
  1. Stain the gel so the DNA bands are visible.
  2. Measure the marker lane from the well to each visible band, or choose Measure all visible bands in lane.
  3. Enter known marker sizes beside their measured distances, largest band closest to the well first.
  4. Use the standard curve to estimate sizes of unknown bands in other lanes. Do not calculate the known marker sizes.

If bands overlap or are too faint to see, record only what you can actually distinguish.

Step-by-step: which numbers go in the marker table?
  1. Find the HindIII marker lane and measure the visible bands, starting at the well.
  2. For each measured marker band, enter the corresponding known size, largest first: 23,130, 9,416, 6,557, 4,361, 2,322, 2,027 bp. Smaller fragments are 564 and 125 bp, but may not be clearly resolved.
  3. Use the resulting standard curve to estimate sizes in the other lanes. You do not calculate the marker sizes with logarithms.

For unknowns: log₁₀(bp) = m × distance + b, so bp = 10(m × distance + b). The site fits this relationship from your marker entries.

How do I know whether my standard-curve estimate is reliable?

Check the graph before using an estimated fragment size in your conclusion.

  1. Check your marker entries. Each known size must match the band you measured. A band farther from the well should generally be smaller.
  2. Look for a clear pattern. Marker points should fall near the fitted line. The R² value describes how closely the points follow that line; a value closer to 1 indicates a better fit, but does not guarantee the measurements are correct.
  3. Check the unknown band. Estimates are more dependable when the unknown's distance falls within the distances covered by your known marker bands. Outside that range, the curve is being extended beyond the measured markers.
  4. Consider measurement uncertainty. Faint, overlapping, or blurry bands can be difficult to locate accurately. Recheck the band or repeat the gel instead of reporting more precision than the evidence supports.

In your conclusion, explain which band measurements you trust most and what limits your confidence. A numerical estimate is evidence, not proof of a DNA match.

Designing and conducting your investigation

Whose blood is on the floor?

The chief investigator (your teacher) gives you DNA from the blood, Ms. Mason (saliva on her cup), Mr. Gladson (his tissue) and Bobby (bubble gum). All four have been cut with the same restriction enzymes, and you also get a HindIII marker. Plan your gel: which wells, how much sample, which voltage, how long, and how many repeat gels. Then run it and size every band. A jury will not accept "the bands look the same." You need fragment sizes and a clear match rule.

Predict first

Before you run your evidence gel, say what you expect: what will a suspect who matches the blood look like on the gel compared with one who does not, and how many repeat gels do you think you need to be confident? Give a reason (1 to 2 sentences).

Different case numbers lead to different suspects. Type the number your teacher assigns. Until you do, this box holds a personal starting number.

Evidence comparison

For each suspect, the table compares their estimated fragment sizes with the blood's. Set your own match rule: how close must two fragments be to count as the same size? Base it on the spread of your repeat measurements.

How do I decide whether the DNA evidence supports a match?
  1. Compare corresponding bands. Use estimated fragment sizes, not just how similar the gel pictures look. Identify bands that match and bands that do not.
  2. Explain your match rule. The percentage tolerance below controls how different two estimated sizes can be and still count as a match. Use the variation in your repeated measurements to justify your choice.
  3. Check for conflicting evidence. Extra, missing, faint, or overlapping bands may affect your interpretation. Do not ignore a clear difference just because several other bands match.
  4. Make a qualified claim. State which suspect's DNA is most consistent with the blood sample, cite specific fragment-size evidence, and describe at least one uncertainty or limitation.

Remember: A matching DNA pattern does not, by itself, establish who committed a crime.

10%
Analyzing results

Make your case

Need to revisit your fragment measurements or match rule? Review the standard-curve steps and evidence comparison before writing your conclusion.

What evidence belongs in my DNA comparison conclusion?
  1. State a claim. Identify whose DNA pattern is most consistent with the blood sample, if any.
  2. Cite measurements. Compare estimated fragment sizes and describe any missing or extra bands.
  3. Justify the match rule. Explain your chosen tolerance using repeated measurements and uncertainty.
  4. State the limits. A DNA-pattern match does not, by itself, prove who committed a crime.
Evaluating results · Thinking about your results

Errors, ethics, and the bigger picture

Go further

Learn how DNA evidence has been used to free wrongly convicted people at innocenceproject.org. Explore interactive DNA-fingerprinting animations from the Dolan DNA Learning Center.

Wrap up

Save and hand in your work